Sandy Tootle
← INNOVATE Real Estate
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 2 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 3 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 4 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 5 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 6 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 7 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 8 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 9 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 10 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 11 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 12 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 13 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 14 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 15 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 16 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 17 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 18 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 19 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 20 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 21 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 22 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 23 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 24 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 25 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 26 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 27 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 28 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 29 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 30 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 31 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 32 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 33 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 34 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 35 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 36 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 37 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 38 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 39 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 40 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 41 of 42
Single Family Residence at 42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474, Arlington, photo 42 of 42
42 photos

$1,998,500

42 Old Mystic Street, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, MA 02474
Listed by Dorothea Feffer
Bedrooms
6
Bathrooms
3.5
Living area
4,000 sqft
Year built
1925

About this home

This distinguished home seamlessly blends classic architectural charm with contemporary amenities, designed for sophisticated living and entertaining. The kitchen is a culinary enthusiast's delight, featuring high-end stainless steel appliances, and a functional island, providing both workspace and a central gathering point. The bathrooms are appointed with modern comforts, including walk-in showers. This residence further benefits from a private yard, an expansive outdoor living space, and a dedicated outdoor dining area, perfect for al fresco entertaining. A convenient laundry room simplifies household tasks.Third floor spacious suite can be accessed by back staircase, with seasonal views of Mystic Lake. Oversized garage allows for ample storage. Many recent updates, new kitchen, baths, electrical, plumbing, heating system. Move right in. Note: Listing agent is Owner.

Highlights

ViewFireplace

Property details

MLS #
73540563
Property type
Single Family Residence
Subdivision
Morningside
Status
Active
Days on market
93
On market date
June 23, 2026
Stories
N/A
Total bathrooms
3.5
Garage spaces
1
Parking spaces
4
Lot size
0.22 acres

Location

Get directions →
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles · public school directory data (NCES)

Elementary
John A Bishop
0.45 mi away · Grades 0-5
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
4.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
390
Student:teacher ratio
13.9:1
District
Arlington
Middle
Ottoson Middle
1.22 mi away · Grades 7-8
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
5.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
906
Student:teacher ratio
11.3:1
District
Arlington
High
Arlington High
0.95 mi away · Grades 9-12
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
4.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
1,483
Student:teacher ratio
13.0:1
District
Arlington

Walkability

Blended score for Arlington's center: EPA's National Walkability Index (street network, transit, land-use mix) combined with nearby-amenity density. 60% EPA National Walkability Index + 40% nearby-amenity density (Google Places).

63
Walkable
out of 100
EPA National Walkability Index
12.2 / 20 -- Above average walkable
Nearby-amenity density
65 / 100
Restaurants & cafes8
Grocery stores1
Parks19
Schools10
Transit stops20
Pharmacies0

Market position

How this listing compares to current activity in Arlington, from live MLS data.

On the market 93 days -- 20 more days than Arlington's current average of 73 days.
For reference, the median list price across 248 active listings in Arlington right now is $249,000.

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

$
%
%
Adjust tax / insurance estimates
% / yr
$
/mo
Est. monthly payment
$12,185/mo
$399,700 down
$1,598,800 loan
Principal & interest$10,370
Property tax (est.)$1,665
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

53 Hodge Rd, Arlington MA 02474
$2,299,000
53 Hodge Rd, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, 02474
5 bd·4 ba·4,275 sqft
6 days on market
Listed by Friel Team
73 Mystic St # 73, Arlington MA 02474
$1,599,000
73 Mystic St # 73, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, 02474
4 bd·4.5 ba·3,119 sqft
8 days on market
305 Ridge Street, Arlington MA 02474
$1,899,900
305 Ridge Street, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, 02474
4 bd·4.5 ba·3,489 sqft
14 days on market
Listed by Bryan Duby
21 Maple Street, Arlington MA 02476
$1,845,000
21 Maple Street, Arlington MA 02476
Arlington, 02476
3 bd·2.5 ba·3,100 sqft
28 days on market
Listed by Yuan Li
323 Ridge St, Arlington MA 02474
$1,619,000
323 Ridge St, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, 02474
4 bd·3 ba·2,000 sqft
28 days on market
Listed by Steve McKenna & The Home Advantage Team
93 Hathaway Circle, Arlington MA 02476
$2,299,000
93 Hathaway Circle, Arlington MA 02476
Arlington, 02476
5 bd·3.5 ba·4,405 sqft
106 days on market
Listed by Julie Gibson
70 Kensington Park, Arlington MA 02476
$1,925,000
70 Kensington Park, Arlington MA 02476
Arlington, 02476
5 bd·3.5 ba·4,051 sqft
114 days on market
Listed by Steve McKenna & The Home Advantage Team
323 Ridge St, Arlington MA 02474
$1,689,000
323 Ridge St, Arlington MA 02474
Arlington, 02474
4 bd·3 ba·2,000 sqft
119 days on market
Listed by Steve McKenna & The Home Advantage Team

Data source: Listing information provided by MLS Property Information Network via Trestle/CoreLogic. Last updated June 29, 2026.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.