Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 2 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 3 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 4 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 5 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 6 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 7 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 8 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 9 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 10 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 11 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 12 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 13 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 14 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 15 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 16 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 17 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 18 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 19 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 20 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 21 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 22 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 23 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 24 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 25 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 26 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 27 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 28 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 29 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 30 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 31 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 32 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 33 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 34 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 35 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 36 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 37 of 38
Single Family Residence at 250 Tanner Street, Rutherfordton, photo 38 of 38
38 photos

$419,999

250 Tanner Street
Rutherfordton, NC 28139
Listed by Michael Olson · Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Elite Properties
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
3
Living area
3,489 sqft
Year built
1987

About this home

Welcome to the "Hill House" a Rutherfordton property with a distinctive character, generous space, and a layout that invites you to create something truly your own. Known in the community as the Hill House, this substantial brick home offers just under 3,500 sq ft of finished living space, plus an additional 325 sq ft enclosed porch that is not included in the heated square footage. You will find 2317 sq ft on the main level, along with 1172 sq ft of finished basement living and an additional 1211 sq ft of unfinished area. More than just a home, this is an opportunity to take a unique property and transform it into a one-of-a-kind personal retreat. The main level features the kitchen with ample cabinet and counter space, breakfast area, dining room, and an oversized living room with a brick fireplace and built-ins. A room with cabinetry just off the foyer and across from the kitchen offers excellent potential for a walk-in pantry, mudroom, or additional storage. The primary bedroom and second bedroom feature a unique arrangement with two en-suite bathrooms sharing a walk-in shower. A third bedroom has the perfect ability to serve as a home office, with a separate laundry room offering additional cabinetry and storage. The full walk-out basement includes two additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a family room, with approximately half of the basement finished and plenty of room to expand. With its separate access and existing layout, the lower level offers exciting potential for a private guest suite or additional living quarters. Recent improvements include two Trane heat pumps and air handlers installed in 2021, a tankless water heater installed in 2022, and an owned propane tank for the gas fireplace logs. Outside, enjoy the covered front porch, deck, vinyl-fenced area ideal for play or pets, expanded driveway, two-car garage with large storage room, and a 20x12 storage building with additional 10x12 lean-to storage. Located conveniently near Rutherford Regional Hospital, Downtown Rutherfordton, recreation, walking trails, and Crestview Park. This is a home with character, space, and endless possibilities to customize, and ready for your personal vision.

Highlights

Fireplace

Property details

MLS
Canopy MLS
MLS #
CAR4421713
Property type
Single Family Residence
Subdivision
Hillcrest
Status
Active
Days on market
15
On market date
September 24, 2026
Stories
N/A
Total bathrooms
3
Garage spaces
2
Parking spaces
N/A
Lot size
N/A
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles. School directory data from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), accessed via the Urban Institute Education Data API. Local Score is calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate; where a state rating is shown, it comes from that state's own official school report card.

Elementary
Rutherfordton Elementary School
1.63 mi away · Grades -1-5
Zoned school (attendance boundary, 2015-16 data)
4.0
Local Score (state rating (2025) blended 70/30 with student-teacher ratio) -- not an official state rating
State rating: B (2025)
Enrollment
383
Student:teacher ratio
13.7:1
District
Rutherford County Schools
Middle
R-S Middle School
1.25 mi away · Grades 6-8
Zoned school (attendance boundary, 2015-16 data)
3.3
Local Score (state rating (2025) blended 70/30 with student-teacher ratio) -- not an official state rating
State rating: C (2025)
Enrollment
603
Student:teacher ratio
14.4:1
District
Rutherford County Schools
High
R-S Central High School
3.15 mi away · Grades 9-12
Zoned school (attendance boundary, 2015-16 data)
3.3
Local Score (state rating (2025) blended 70/30 with student-teacher ratio) -- not an official state rating
State rating: C (2025)
Enrollment
769
Student:teacher ratio
13.7:1
District
Rutherford County Schools

Walkability

Blended score for Rutherfordton's center, calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate from two sources: the EPA's National Walkability Index (street network, transit, land-use mix) and Google Places amenity data (what's actually reachable on foot from this point). EPA National Walkability Index only -- nearby-amenity data not cached yet for this area.

33
Car-dependent
out of 100
EPA National Walkability Index
6.7 / 20 -- Below average walkable

Market position

How this listing compares to current activity in Rutherfordton, from live MLS data.

On the market 15 days -- 204 fewer days than Rutherfordton's current average of 219 days.
For reference, the median list price across 311 active listings in Rutherfordton right now is $154,000.

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

$
%
%
Adjust tax / insurance estimates
% / yr
$
/mo
Est. monthly payment
$2,679/mo
$84,000 down
$335,999 loan
Principal & interest$2,179
Property tax (est.)$350
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

Data source: Listing information provided by Canopy MLS (carolina) via Trestle/CoreLogic. Last updated 7 days ago.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.