SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 2 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 3 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 4 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 5 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 6 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 7 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 8 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 9 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 10 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 11 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 12 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 13 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 14 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 15 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 16 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 17 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 18 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 19 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 20 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 21 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 22 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 23 of 49
Main Level laundry room - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Main level full bathroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Main level full bathroom. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 27 of 49
2nd bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
2nd bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
3rd bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
3rd Bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
4th bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
4th bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
2nd level full bath - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
2nd level full bath - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Walk out lower level - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 37 of 49
Kitchen area in lower level. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Kitchen area in lower level. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Lower level recreation area. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Lower Level 5th bedroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Lower level 5th bedroom. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Lower level full bathroom - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
Hallway to access to garage. - 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 45 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 46 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 47 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 48 of 49
SingleFamilyResidence at 1 Cayuse Trail, Malvern, photo 49 of 49
49 photos

$624,900

1 Cayuse Trail
Malvern, OH 44644
Listed by Robyn R Clark · Cutler Real Estate
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4
Living area
4,207 sqft
Year built
2005

About this home

Welcome home to your own private retreat at Lake Mohawk! Nestled on a spacious double lot, this custom-built Colonial offers over 4,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, combining comfort, efficiency, and room to entertain in every season. This 5-bedroom, 4-full-bath home features 9-foot ceilings throughout, an open and inviting floor plan, and eco-friendly geothermal/electric heating and cooling. The heart of the home is the beautifully appointed kitchen with quartz countertops, a large center island, stainless steel appliances, hardwood floors, and seamless flow into the dining area and great room. Cozy up by the propane fireplace or gather with friends and family for memorable evenings together. The spacious main-level owner's suite is a true retreat, complete with a massive walk-in closet, double vanity with quartz countertops, Jacuzzi tub, walk-in shower, and private deck access—perfect for morning coffee or unwinding under the stars. An additional room on the main level offers flexibility for a home office, den, or hobby space. Main-floor laundry includes a utility sink and storage closet for added convenience. The finished walk-out lower level adds over 1,600 square feet of living space and includes a second kitchen (no range), bedroom, full bath, wood-burning stove, and direct access to the oversized three-car garage—ideal for guests, multi-generational living, or entertaining. Outside, you'll love the professionally landscaped yard, concrete driveway, and two expansive decks. One deck is located off the kitchen and designed for outdoor gatherings, while the second provides a peaceful escape just outside the primary suite. Additional updates include a new hot water tank (2025) and water softener (2024). Enjoy all that Lake Mohawk has to offer, including a 500-acre lake, unlimited horsepower boating, beaches, clubhouse, tennis/pickleball courts, golf course, and year-round community events. This is more than a home—it's a lifestyle!

Highlights

ViewFireplace

Property details

MLS
NOWDD
MLS #
5218191
Property type
SingleFamilyResidence
Subdivision
Lake Mohawk
Status
Active
Days on market
34
On market date
June 13, 2026
Stories
2
Total bathrooms
4
Garage spaces
3
Parking spaces
N/A
Lot size
0.914 acres
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles. School directory data from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), accessed via the Urban Institute Education Data API. Local Score is calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate; where a state rating is shown, it comes from that state's own official school report card.

Elementary
Malvern Elementary School
3.17 mi away · Grades 0-5
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
272
Student:teacher ratio
16.0:1
District
Brown Local
Middle
Malvern Middle School
3.17 mi away · Grades 6-8
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
2.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
155
Student:teacher ratio
19.4:1
District
Brown Local
High
Malvern High School
3.17 mi away · Grades 9-12
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
5.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
197
Student:teacher ratio
10.9:1
District
Brown Local

Walkability

Blended score for Malvern's center, calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate from two sources: the EPA's National Walkability Index (street network, transit, land-use mix) and Google Places amenity data (what's actually reachable on foot from this point). 60% EPA National Walkability Index + 40% nearby-amenity density (Google Places).

9
Very car-dependent
out of 100
EPA National Walkability Index
3.0 / 20 -- Least walkable
Google Places amenity density
0 / 100
Restaurants & cafes0
Grocery stores0
Parks0
Schools0
Transit stops0
Pharmacies0

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

$
%
%
Adjust tax / insurance estimates
% / yr
$
/mo
Est. monthly payment
$3,913/mo
$124,980 down
$499,920 loan
Principal & interest$3,242
Property tax (est.)$521
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

Data source: Listing information provided by NOWDD via Trestle/CoreLogic. Last updated July 17, 2026.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.