INNOVATE Real Estate
Rear view of house with a porch, a chimney, and a yard - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Hardwood cabinets on left area pass-through to dining room for serving - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
SingleFamilyResidence at 537 3rd Street, Elyria, photo 3 of 13
Bathroom with Laundry room with light wood-style floors and separate washer and dryer - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
dark wood-style flooring, a ceiling fan, wooden walls - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Living room with hardwood / wood-style floors, a brick fireplace, and ceiling fan - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
View of staircase - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Unfurnished bedroom with lofted ceiling and baseboards - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Half bath with dark wood finished floors and vanity - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Unfurnished room with wood finished floors, a ceiling fan, and wallpapered walls - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
New Furnace - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
View of unfinished basement - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
Garage in generous back yard - 537 3rd Street, Elyria
13 photos

$59,900

537 3rd Street
Elyria, OH 44035
Listed by Jeanette K Smith · Russell Real Estate Services
Bedrooms
3
Bathrooms
1.5
Living area
1,538 sqft
Year built
1900

About this home

Traditional century home with spacious living spaces and large eat-in kitchen. Garage in back, and HUGE back yard made for playing, planting or your heart's desire. Hardwood floors in many rooms, with built-in pass-through hardwood cabinets in kitchen leading to dining room for serving. Great home for first time home buyers and those wishing to put their own stamp on this home! Furnace NEW in 2024, roof replaced in 2005.

Highlights

Fireplace

Property details

MLS #
5170573
Property type
SingleFamilyResidence
Subdivision
Wm Turners
Status
Active
Days on market
249
On market date
November 6, 2025
Stories
2
Total bathrooms
1.5
Garage spaces
1
Parking spaces
N/A
Lot size
0.25 acres

Location

Get directions →
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles. School directory data from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), accessed via the Urban Institute Education Data API. Local Score is calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate; where a state rating is shown, it comes from that state's own official school report card (e.g. NC Dept. of Public Instruction, SC Report Card).

Elementary
Hamilton Elementary School
0.79 mi away · Grades -1-4
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
411
Student:teacher ratio
16.4:1
District
Elyria City Schools
Middle
Eastern Heights Middle School
1.3 mi away · Grades 5-8
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
704
Student:teacher ratio
16.8:1
District
Elyria City Schools
High
Elyria High School
0.38 mi away · Grades 9-12
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
1,667
Student:teacher ratio
16.2:1
District
Elyria City Schools

Walkability

Blended score for Elyria's center, calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate from two sources: the EPA's National Walkability Index (street network, transit, land-use mix) and Google Places amenity data (what's actually reachable on foot from this point). 60% EPA National Walkability Index + 40% nearby-amenity density (Google Places).

46
Somewhat walkable
out of 100
EPA National Walkability Index
5.0 / 20 -- Least walkable
Google Places amenity density
78 / 100
Restaurants & cafes11
Grocery stores1
Parks5
Schools9
Transit stops15
Pharmacies1

Market position

How this listing compares to current activity in Elyria, from live MLS data.

On the market 249 days -- 164 more days than Elyria's current average of 85 days.
For reference, the median list price across 136 active listings in Elyria right now is $149,950.

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

$
%
%
Adjust tax / insurance estimates
% / yr
$
/mo
Est. monthly payment
$511/mo
$11,980 down
$47,920 loan
Principal & interest$311
Property tax (est.)$50
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

127 Belmont Avenue
New
$49,900
127 Belmont Avenue
Elyria, 44035
3 bd·1 ba·768 sqft
1 day on market
Listed by Phil Rogers, Russell Real Estate Services
144 Virginia Avenue
$59,000
144 Virginia Avenue
Elyria, 44035
3 bd·2 ba·1,280 sqft
45 days on market
Listed by Leilani M Bowersock, Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty
108 Rush Street
$58,000
108 Rush Street
Elyria, 44035
2 bd·1 ba·0 sqft
35 days on market
Listed by Kim Lewis, Home Equity Realty Group

Data source: Listing information provided by NOWDD via Trestle/CoreLogic. Last updated July 13, 2026.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.