Skip to main content
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 2 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 3 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 4 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 5 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 6 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 7 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 8 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 9 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 10 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 11 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 12 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 13 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 14 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 15 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 16 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 17 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 18 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 19 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 20 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 21 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 22 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 23 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 24 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 25 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 26 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 27 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 28 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 29 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 30 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 31 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 32 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 33 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 34 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 35 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 36 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 37 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 38 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 39 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 40 of 41
Single Family Residence at 16 Cottage St, West Brookfield, photo 41 of 41
41 photos

$474,900

Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
3
Living area
2,107 sqft
Year built
1875
16 Cottage St
West Brookfield, MA 01585
Listed by Post Road Realty

Highlights

Property type
Single Family Residence
Lot size
0.5 acres
Garage
1 space
On market
27 days

About this home

HISTORIC CHARM, TIMELESS CHARACTER & ENDLESS POSSIBILITIES IN BEAUTIFUL WEST BROOKFIELD! Welcome to the Myron W. Sherman House, a beautiful Greek Revival-style home filled with classic New England charm! Ideally situated in the heart of picturesque West Brookfield, this well-maintained property offers 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, gorgeous wide pine floors throughout, and wonderful architectural details that make this home truly special. From the moment you step into the beautiful entryway, you'll appreciate the warmth and character this home has to offer! The first floor boasts impressive 9+ foot ceilings, creating an open, airy feel throughout the main living areas. The huge living room provides an abundance of space for comfortable everyday living and entertaining, while the formal dining room features a beautiful custom-built hutch that adds to the home's historic charm. The convenience of first-floor laundry makes everyday living even easier. Just off the kitchen, a lovely three-season sun porch offers the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee, relax with a good book, or simply unwind while overlooking the backyard. Step outside onto the deck overlooking the spacious, flat, level backyard, offering plenty of room for outdoor gatherings, gardening, recreation, and entertaining. **AND THE POSSIBILITIES DON'T END THERE!** The attached garage offers an abundance of additional space above with exciting potential for future finished living space, a private home office, art studio, hobby room, or possibly an accessory dwelling unit (ADU), subject to buyer verification of zoning, permitted uses, and required approvals. The storage shed provides even more room for tools and equipment. Enjoy the convenience of being in the heart of beautiful West Brookfield, close to the town library, Town Hall, local shops, and the picturesque town common. And as an added bonus, scenic Lake Wickaboag is located right at the end of the street! Passing Title 5 inspection in hand! With its beautiful Greek Revival-style architecture, impressive living spaces, gorgeous wide pine floors, wonderful outdoor areas, and incredible possibilities, this special property offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of West Brookfield's history and make it your own!

Property details

MLS
MLS Property Information Network
MLS #
73595052
Property type
Single Family Residence
Subdivision
N/A
Status
Active
Days on market
27 days
On market date
October 26, 2026
Stories
N/A
Total bathrooms
3
Garage spaces
1
Parking spaces
4
Lot size
0.5 acres
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles. School directory data from the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), accessed via the Urban Institute Education Data API. Local Score is calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate; where a state rating is shown, it comes from that state's own official school report card.

Elementary
West Brookfield Elementary
0.53 mi away · Grades PK-6
Nearest school (attendance-zone data not available here)
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary, will incorporate state test-score data once available)), not an official state rating
Enrollment
247
Student:teacher ratio
15.4:1
District
Quaboag Regional
Middle
Quaboag Regional Middle Innovation School
2.51 mi away · Grades 7-8
Nearest school (attendance-zone data not available here)
3.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary, will incorporate state test-score data once available)), not an official state rating
Enrollment
200
Student:teacher ratio
15.4:1
District
Quaboag Regional
High
Quaboag Regional High
2.51 mi away · Grades 9-12
Nearest school (attendance-zone data not available here)
5.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary, will incorporate state test-score data once available)), not an official state rating
Enrollment
341
Student:teacher ratio
10.3:1
District
Quaboag Regional

Walkability

Blended score for West Brookfield's center, calculated by INNOVATE Real Estate from two sources: the EPA's National Walkability Index (street network, transit, land-use mix) and Google Places amenity data (what's actually reachable on foot from this point). 60% EPA National Walkability Index + 40% nearby-amenity density (Google Places).

29
Car-dependent
out of 100
EPA National Walkability Index
5.5 / 20 (Least walkable)
Google Places amenity density
32 / 100
Restaurants & cafes8
Grocery stores0
Parks1
Schools0
Transit stops2
Pharmacies0

Market position

How this listing compares to current activity in West Brookfield, from live MLS data.

On the market 27 days, 43 fewer days than West Brookfield's current average of 70 days.
For reference, the median list price across 39 active listings in West Brookfield right now is $446,950.

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

Adjust tax / insurance estimates
Est. monthly payment
$3,010/mo
$94,980 down
$379,920 loan
Principal & interest$2,464
Property tax (est.)$396
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

Data source: Listing information provided by MLS Property Information Network. Last updated 8 days ago.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.