WELCOME TO 1204 NOTTINGHAM STREET! - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 2 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 3 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 4 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 5 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 6 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 7 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 8 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 9 of 76
LET'S TAKE A LOOK INSIDE! - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 11 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 12 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 13 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 14 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 15 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 16 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 17 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 18 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 19 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 20 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 21 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 22 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 23 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 24 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 25 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 26 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 27 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 28 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 29 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 30 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 31 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 32 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 33 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 34 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 35 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 36 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 37 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 38 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 39 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 40 of 76
POOL BATH / POWDER ROOM - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 42 of 76
PRIMARY SUITE - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 44 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 45 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 46 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 47 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 48 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 49 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 50 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 51 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 52 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 53 of 76
FOYER - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
DECICATED PRIVATE OFFICE - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 56 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 57 of 76
GUEST BEDROOM SUITE - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 59 of 76
BEDROOM SUITE #3 - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 61 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 62 of 76
BEDROOM SUITE #4 - 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 64 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 65 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 66 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 67 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 68 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 69 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 70 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 71 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 72 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 73 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 74 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 75 of 76
Single Family Residence at 1204 NOTTINGHAM ST, ORLANDO, photo 76 of 76
76 photos

$2,995,000

1204 NOTTINGHAM ST
ORLANDO, FL 32803
Listed by Robert Kurzreiter PA · KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY AT THE PARKS
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
4.2
Living area
3,689 sqft
Year built
2026

About this home

A REFINED CUSTOM SINGLE-STORY RESIDENCE WITH CASITA BY M. LAHR HOMES! Located in the highly sought-after Beverly Shores / Rose Isle neighborhood of Orlando / Winter Park, this newly completed custom residence represents a rare opportunity in one of Central Florida’s most desirable and seldom-available areas. This home reflects the level of craftsmanship, detail, and execution that has made the builder one of the most respected names in Winter Park and Orlando luxury construction. Thoughtfully designed as a large single-story residence, the main home offers an expansive beautifully planned living space with 4 bedrooms, a private office, 4.5 baths, and a layout that balances scale, functionality, and everyday livability. Adding to the rarity of the offering is the casita / secondary living space, creating exceptional flexibility for guests, extended family, private work space, or additional lifestyle needs. From the moment of arrival, the home conveys a sense of timeless design and quality. Inside, the experience is defined by a clean, cohesive aesthetic and a level of finish that is simply not typical in today’s new construction market. Every element, from the architectural lines to the material selections, has been intentionally executed, resulting in a home that feels both elevated and enduring. The floor plan is open and highly functional, with expansive living areas that transition seamlessly to the outdoor environment, creating a natural extension of the interior living space. The result is a home that lives comfortably day-to-day while offering the scale, presence, and design quality expected at this level. Opportunities in Beverly Shores / Rose Isle rarely present themselves, and large single-story custom homes with a casita are especially difficult to find. This is one of those moments. What ultimately sets this property apart is the consistency of its execution, a level of detail, craftsmanship, and finish quality that is rarely achieved, even among competing new construction offerings in Winter Park and Orlando. Located in a fantastic location in the highly desirable Audubon Park School K-8 School District. Minutes to Downtown Orlando, Downtown Winter Park, Winter Park’s Park Avenue, Winter Park Village, AdventHealth, ORMC, shopping, dining, and more. An exquisite luxury estate in one of Central Florida’s most dynamic and desirable areas!

Highlights

Private poolFireplaceNew construction

Property details

MLS #
MFRO6425268
Property type
Single Family Residence
Subdivision
BEVERLY SHORES
Status
Active
Days on market
32
On market date
July 16, 2026
Stories
N/A
Total bathrooms
6
Garage spaces
2
Parking spaces
N/A
Lot size
0.3 acres
Loading map…

Nearby schools

Within 10 miles · public school directory data (NCES)

Elementary
PRINCETON ELEMENTARY
1.36 mi away · Grades -1-5
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
4.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
444
Student:teacher ratio
14.8:1
District
ORANGE
Middle
ORLANDO GIFTED ACADEMY
1.43 mi away · Grades 2-8
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
5.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
321
Student:teacher ratio
11.5:1
District
ORANGE
High
EDGEWATER HIGH
1.63 mi away · Grades 9-12
Nearest school -- attendance-zone data not available here
1.0
Local Score (student-teacher ratio only (preliminary -- will incorporate state test-score data once available)) -- not an official state rating
Enrollment
1,993
Student:teacher ratio
23.4:1
District
ORANGE

Mortgage calculator

Estimate only - actual rate and payment depend on your lender, credit, and loan program.

$
%
%
Adjust tax / insurance estimates
% / yr
$
/mo
Est. monthly payment
$18,186/mo
$599,000 down
$2,396,000 loan
Principal & interest$15,540
Property tax (est.)$2,496
Home insurance (est.)$150

Similar homes you might like

Data source: Listing information provided by Stellar MLS (mfrmls) via Trestle/CoreLogic. Last updated 1 days ago.

Information herein deemed reliable but not guaranteed; all measurements, school assignments, HOA fees, taxes, and feature lists are approximate and should be independently verified. Equal Housing Opportunity.